How to speak CFO: The commercial fluency gap between Marketing Director and CMO

4 minutes

Despite being successful brand builders, creatives and people leaders, transitioning from the Marketing Director role to the Chief Marketing Officer role is not simple. Separating them from C-suite leadership is often a commercial fluency gap. In order to bridge that gap you must build a tailored lerarning and devlopment plan to be able to confidently demonstrate that you're not only a marketing leader, but a business leader. 

This article looks at why the commercial fluency gap exists and offers advice on how Marketing Directors can bridge it to become CMOs.


Why does the commercial fluency gap exist?


As a Marketing Director, your role is largely focused on campaigns, customers and brand narratives. Consequently, you are measured on your creative and cultural impact rather than commerciality. Yet, in order to progress your career and step up to the CMO role, you must be able to speak the language of the Chief Financial Officer.  

Opportunities to learn the commercial elements of a business do not come organically within the Marketing Director role, which can ultimately prevent progression. As such, Marketing Directors moving to the CMO role must build a tailored upskilling, learning and development plan. 


How to build commercial skills as a Marketing Director?


Building commercial skills requires a structured, purposeful approach. We recommend taking the following four steps:

  1. Own a P&L
  2. Think like a business leader
  3. Build a genuine relationship with your CFO
  4. Invest in structured learning


1. Own a profit and loss (P&L) statement

Numerous experienced C-suite marketers that we've interviewed at 3Search Events report that understanding the P&L was the key to unlocking their progression. However, Marketing Directors can be shielded from the numbers. While in theory you're a P&L leader, in reality your budget is ultimately managed by someone else. This makes it challenging to understand what a P&L looks like. 

The most direct way of learning how the P&L works is to lead or own one. While reading about it helps, having accountability for the numbers will give you a practical application that changes your mindset.

Campaign metrics do not hold much weight in a finance meeting. Once you understand the numbers, you must be able to translate marketing results into commercial results such as revenue, margin, payback and growth. Knowledge of digital channels will help, because understanding what works, and why, gives you the raw material to describe what commercial success looks like.


2. Think like a business leader, not a function head

Mindset is equally as important as understanding the numbers. As a CMO you are a business leader, and so are expected to have a clear and decisive opinion on what the business should do and why. Consequently, you must understand the key performance indicators (KPIs) that matter to the entire business, not just marketing. To confidently operate in the C-suite, you must build an understanding of how finance, sales, operations and HR operate, and the pressures they face. 


3. Build a genuine relationship with your CFO

Your relationship with the CFO is possibly the most important one you'll have on the route to CMO, so make sure it's a two-way exchange. Early on, you might find it helpful to teach each other about your worlds. You'll never know as much about the numbers as the CFO does, and the CFO will never know as much about marketing as you do, but learning enough about each other's role will allow you to meet in the middle.

Finance teams often see marketing as a cost. Rather than resenting it, help them understand why the investment is important, particularly at the top of the funnel. Structuring and building the budget alongside them, explaining your thinking as you go, will increase their understanding.

As with any relationship, it will depend very much on the person – so start by understanding where your CFO is coming from, what motivates them and where your needs overlap. If the CFO is hard to access, find an ally in the finance team who is happy to spend time walking you through the numbers.


4. Invest in structured learning

Formal learning is an effective way of accelerating your commerciality. The Chartered Institute of Marketing (CIM) offers short courses on reading and translating the numbers and working effectively with finance, such as:

Online mini-MBAs, usually two to three months long, are available from well-known business schools if you want a recognisable name on your CV.

These programmes help marketers to understand and translate finance data, and hold meaningful conversations with the CFO in a language they understand.


Develop your career with 3Search Executive


Ultimately, to transition from Marketing Director to Chief Marketing Officer, you cannot simply upskill within the marketing field. You must become a more rounded business leader who specialises in marketing. By...

  • Taking ownership of a P&L
  • Shifting your mindset to think like a business leader
  • Building a real partnership with your CFO 
  • Reinforcing your knowledge with formal learning

...you will build the commerciality you need to progress.

These insights were derived from our recent seminar on The leadership journey from Marketing Director to CMO. If you'd like to join us at our next event or to talk to us about taking the step up to CMO, please get in touch with specialist marketing headhunters.